Critic Critique Thyself
Though the official reason for the recent AdAge.com redesign was to make it more "reader friendly," in truth it's anything but.
While the previous version was straightforward and easy to navigate, the "new and improved" is a fragmented, frustrating mess that emphasizes graphics
over ease of use
Ad critic Bob Garfield's column has been separated from the main magazine content and shifted to a spin-off site called AdReview.com.
Garfield probably doesn't have reason to search his own archives because if he did, he might be critical of the fact that they somehow got lost in the move
The old AdAge.com site had a straightforward list of Garfield archives dating back to 1995. Only a dozen or so recent ones can be unearthed on the new site.
And the dysfunctional search engine isn't good for anything but challenging
your sanity.
Perhaps AdReview's design is an attempt to reflect many of the spots it features--all
style, no substance.
...
Please donate to keep adland alive. The Super Bowl Collection is the worlds one and only. It costs a minor fortune to keep up. If you love our efforts, please donate to keep the archive alive. You may also sponsor us with a large banner, advertise yourself as you help save our common advertising history.
Want to join adland?
Create an adgrunt account for 6 USD.
comments
- What, no pitchforks and
5 hours 53 min ago - Worth it for your dream
5 hours 53 min ago - I could care less about the
6 hours 55 min ago - Okay, it may be hokey in some
19 hours 50 min ago - What is the name of the song
3 days 17 hours ago - With this card, they're
3 days 22 hours ago - Haha as well as "Why is it?"
4 days 5 hours ago - This was all so much better
4 days 9 hours ago - This wasn't an Abercrombie
5 days 2 hours ago - This just makes me like
5 days 2 hours ago


Post new comment